The atmosphere in Beijing has changed noticeably in recent months; and many liberal-minded people here now fear that the government of Xi Jinping has made a sharp turn towards authoritarianism.

As nearly three thousand Communist Party delegates gather in the capital for the National People’s Congress, this is clearly a critical time for China’s economy.

The rate of growth is down yet again, and although that by itself doesn’t necessarily make the Chinese government unhappy, it does mean a greater possibility of a so-called hard landing for the economy, with worrying effects on people’s jobs and their standard of living.

The American ratings agency Moody’s has cut its outlook for China from “stable” to “negative”.

“The real economy is suffering big time,” says Liu Qian, the director of the Economist Intelligence Unit’s China service.

“If anything, I’d say that 2016 is the most critical year for the Chinese economy in the past decade or so.”

Liu Qian Economist Intelligence Unit (Director, China Service)
Image captionEconomist Liu Qian has concerns about the Chinese economy

Absolute loyalty

If things turn out awkwardly here, there’s always the possible danger of social unrest: the one thing any Chinese government dreads.

And so President Xi Jinping is pulling up the drawbridge.

Two weeks ago he made his new approach unmistakably clear. On a single day, he visited the main Communist Party newspaper, the state news agency, and state television.

In each place he told the staff they must be absolutely loyal to the Communist Party and follow its leadership in thought, politics and action.

At CCTV the staff welcomed him with a banner which read “Central Television’s family name is The Party”. And, not by coincidence, he told them: “The media run by the Party and the government… must have the Party as their family name.”

What he is demanding from the state broadcaster, the main newspaper, and the national news agency is nothing short of total loyalty to the Party line, and to his own leadership.

Echoes of Maoism

For some people here, that’s uncomfortably reminiscent of 1970s Maoism. They talk nervously of a new Cultural Revolution, Mao Zedong’s hugely destructive campaign to destroy his enemies.

A leading pro-government academic, Wang Yukai, who teaches at a top school for Party officials insists that this view is mistaken.

“Seen from the outside, it might look as though our top leadership has become more aggressive. However, this aggressiveness won’t last long.”

“In order to solve the current economic and social problems that China faces now, these strong measures are understandable.”

“China needs a stronger government in order to govern our country and society effectively.”

Xi JinpingOthers see the new hint of authoritarianism as a sign that the top leadership is feeling decidedly vulnerable. Zhang Lifan, an outspoken independent historian, thinks Mr Xi feels a crisis is approaching.

“He is worried that he will lose the rule of the Chinese Communist Party. He is also worried that he might be replaced by his peers.”

“For those reasons, he must hold on to his power tightly. He’s like a man who doesn’t know how to swim. He is going to grab hold of whatever he can.”

In the new climate, these might be difficult opinions to voice. Does Mr Zhang feel nervous?

“The fact that I can still talk is quite an exception. I don’t know for how much longer, though.”

A thin-skinned leader

President Xi has some important advantages. He is unquestionably popular. People associate him with China’s economic success and with its impressive new standing in the world, and they’re proud of what has been achieved.

He has cleaned out any potential opposition in the armed forces. The anti-corruption campaign, which is also hugely popular, has enabled him to get rid of many of his political opponents in the upper ranks of the Communist Party.

Even so, he still seems remarkably thin-skinned. The case of the five Hong Kong booksellers, who vanished in October after they had stocked books purporting to give details of the private lives and power struggles of China’s political elite, is particularly disturbing.

Screengrab of image of Lee Bo in 29 February 2016 television interview with Phoenix TV, as posted on Phoenix TV's website
The booksellers have appeared on Chinese TV “confessing” to their crimes

The books themselves are scarcely serious. One which I have seen is simply softish porn using Mr Xi as a character. It’s absurd and trivial. Yet the full weight of the Chinese Communist Party’s anger has fallen on the five men who sold these books.

In spite of the supposedly separate status of Hong Kong, four of the booksellers have appeared on television in mainland China and “confessed” to various crimes in grovelling terms, in a way which is unpleasantly reminiscent of the Cultural Revolution.

One is a Swedish citizen. The other was British, though he claims he has now renounced his British nationality.

Exit strategies

Britain has protested that this is a clear breach of the “One country, two systems” agreement under which Hong Kong was handed back to China in 1997.

But the Chinese government has noted with considerable satisfaction that Britain’s response was noticeably more muted than that of the United States. The new, closer relationship between China and Britain seems to be paying off – for China.

Senior government and Party figures insist that China won’t move away from the path of greater democracy for long.

But the sense of nervousness among better-off people here is growing.

Many wealthy Chinese are getting their money out of the country, and they’re sending their children to school and university in Western countries, particularly Britain and the United States.

They hope the latest crack-down won’t last. But they aren’t taking any chances.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here